
Sarah Abood
We note the Minister’s statement as part of his ASFA Conference speech yesterday, that legislation will be introduced to parliament next week to enable substantial broadening of the scope of advice that can be collectively charged by super funds.
At this time, the legislation has not yet been made publicly available. The detail will be important, and we will have more to say as soon as the specifics emerge.
However, if the scope is similar to what Minister Stephen Jones announced in March 2025, we will have similar concerns to those we expressed at the time.
As the professional association for financial advice, our key concerns surround the impact on consumers as they navigate retirement planning – a highly complex area of financial advice:
- Members will presumably only receive collectively charged advice at retirement from their super fund to invest in whatever retirement products their fund has available. As Treasury notes in its recent paper on Innovative Retirement Income Stream (IRIS) products, most funds currently only offer their members account-based pensions. Thus, members of those funds would not receive any advice on annuities – an entire class of retirement income products that might better suit their needs.
Even if an account-based pension is the right structure, there is no publicly available tool that would enable members to fairly compare their fund’s offering with what is available elsewhere.
- Insulating funds from competition and limiting consumer choice at the point of retirement is likely to substantially reduce the pressure on those funds to innovate and make improvements to their own offerings. Over time this will have a substantially negative effect on the quality of retirement outcomes.
- Advice needs at retirement go well beyond the best choice of retirement income product. One pertinent example is the fact that increasing numbers of Australians are retiring with mortgage debt. Recent research from Vanguard shows that almost half of Gen Z Australians, and more than one third of Millennials, expect to retire with a mortgage.
Deciding whether to use some or all of your super to pay off your mortgage at or in retirement is a complex decision, and there is no one right answer. We do not think that a super fund, which of course has the prime incentive of retaining member funds, is best placed to offer this important advice impartially and fairly.
- We are unsure at this stage as to whether retirement advice would be able to be offered by the proposed “New Class of Adviser” (NCA). However given the focus on intrafund charging in this announcement, it seems a likely outcome. Advice at retirement is highly consequential, and highly complex, and professional financial advisers receive years of tertiary level training to ensure they can give this advice competently and in the interests of their clients. NCAs will have substantially less training and are unlikely to have sufficient knowledge to safely provide this highly complex form of advice to consumers.
- This much broader scope of advice will be much more expensive for funds to provide than the current intrafund advice model – which is limited to the member’s interest in the fund. If collectively charged, these much greater costs will be borne by other members of the fund: including those who have already paid for their own financial advice, and including younger members who will be forced to pay for advice to retirees. This is fundamentally unfair.
The Hayne Royal Commission found many examples of misconduct on the part of vertically integrated product manufacturers whose financial advice to their clients was seriously flawed. It would be a very great pity if the lessons of that review were lost. We must not turn back the clock to the days when financial institutions used ‘advice’ as a sales channel for their own products.
Super funds can and do already offer comprehensive retirement advice to their members under the current rules. Many of our members are working successfully within super funds to offer their members advice across the full spectrum of retirement topics, paid for by the members who need it.
Retirement advice is currently complex and expensive to offer, and we recognise that change is needed to ensure more Australians can access the advice they need. We remain ready and willing to engage with government and key stakeholders to ensure high quality financial advice can be more accessible to the increasing numbers of Australians who desperately need it.